web embed
UX Research Methods · University of Miami · 2024
Mangrove City
Mid-game completion fell from 100% to 0%.
Our findings helped cut those drop-offs by about 70%.
Ayushi Choudhary, with Mikeiveka Sanon, Shuai Xiao and Weili Xu
web embed
The game
A VR game that teaches middle schoolers why mangroves matter
Six education stations
Play
Paddle a canal through a future coastal city, mini-games at six education stations
Platform
Meta Quest 2, single player, 20 to 30 minutes
Built by
An interdisciplinary team at the University of Miami
web embed
Inside the game
Players paddle the canal and stop at stations for mini-games
First-person view paddling a canal through mangroves toward a Birding Station sign
Paddling the canal
Mangrove Identification station: drag mangrove names onto their images
Mangrove Identification
Drag each name onto its mangrove
Fish Identification station: match juvenile fish with adult fish
Fish Identification
Match juvenile fish to adults
Food Web station: a watercolor mangrove scene where players click predators to match their prey
Food Web
Click predators to match their prey
web embed
My role and method
I planned the study and helped turn it into answers
My role
Wrote the test plan
Moderated 2 sessions, observed 2 more
Co-led the synthesis
The study
4 players, 6 tasks, think-aloud
Success scored 0, 0.5 or 1
Time on task, SEQ and SUS
web embed
The drop-off
Everyone finished the first two stations. Nobody finished the third alone.
Players who completed each task on their own
Task 1
Task 2
Task 3
Task 4
Task 5
Task 6
Task 3, planting mangroves
3 of 4 needed help.
338 seconds on average vs 270 expected.
Whole game
SUS score 30.6, a grade F.
web embed
Why it happened
37 issues logged, three of them behind most of the drop-off
01
Planting had no clear mechanic
Too little space, no cue for how to grab or where to drop
02
Instructions broke expectations
The last station was explore-only, but players expected a task
03
Players couldn’t leave
The exit button didn’t work
19 unique problems · 10 hit by most players · 7 rated high severity
web embed
How we chose
We ranked 19 problems by severity, reach and whether they blocked players
Severity (Rubin’s 1 to 4 scale)
4
3
2
1
1
2
3
4
Players who hit it (of 4)
Fish, audio
Planting and farm instructions
Exit
How we prioritized
1
How severe is it?
2
How many players hit it?
3
Does it stop players finishing?
Exit scored lower but hit every player. We designed end to end, and a great game that ends badly leaves a bad last impression.
web embed
What we recommended
Give players clarity and control at every station
Planting mechanic
Instructions
Exit and control
Before
Too little space, no cue for how to grab or where to drop
After
More space, a clear grab-and-drop gesture, stations at a comfortable reach
Before
The last station was explore-only, but players expected a task
After
Museum-style signage, an always-on info button, explore-only stations labelled upfront
Before
The exit button didn’t work
After
A working exit, Play again, replay and stop for audio, a progress tracker
Our redesign mockups
Mockup: museum-style sign at the Aquaponic Farm listing its two levels
Museum-style signage introduces each station
Mockup: prompt showing a controller, press and hold the trigger to drag a mangrove
Press and hold the trigger to grab, release to drop
Mockup: Aquaponic Farm instructions panel with controller diagrams and an info button
Instructions on arrival, reopened any time from the info button
Mockup: closing sign reading Thank you for visiting Mangrove City, with Replay and Exit buttons
A closing screen with Replay and Exit
web embed
The result
fewer mid-game drop-offs after the redesign
Task completion measured by the game’s design team after they implemented our recommendations: 6 players before vs 6 players after.
web embed
What it taught me
Players decide to stay in the moments between the fun
01
Clarity is part of the fun
02
Control builds trust
03
Protect what players love
“I love how we can see the paddle board. It’s fun. I really like it.”
Participant, start of the game
“Here it is really beautiful, I feel in the scene.”
Participant, aquaponic farm